Boeing struggling with Mt. Everest PR challenge

09/05/2019 | 804 words

No amount of public relations spin can repair the reputational hit from two deadly plane crashes. But Boeing may have further damaged itself with muddled communications that downplayed its responsibility in the disasters.

Chief Executive Dennis Muilenburg has insisted there was "no surprise or gap" in the design of the top-selling 737 MAX aircraft, even as the company works to correct issues and persuade regulators that a software update should be enough clear the planes to fly again.

The plane has been grounded worldwide since the March 10 crash of an Ethiopian Airlines flight plunged the company into crisis mode. It came on the heels of an October crash of a Lion Air flight in Indonesia, two accidents that claimed 346 lives.

"We own it," Muilenburg has said of the crisis.

But some aviation and public relations experts said the Boeing CEO has tried to walk back that buck-stops-here sentiment by blaming the crashes on a "chain of events" with "no singular" cause.

"You can't follow one consistent train of thought on anything that's come out of Chicago," Jim Hall, former head of the National Transportation Safety Board, said of Boeing's leadership.

"I don't think they've been credible or responsible in the information they've provided," he said in an interview. "They certainly haven't been transparent."

And aviation expert Richard Aboulafia of the Teal Group said Boeing has been "a little bit more defensive than they need to be."

"They really need to stick with taking ownership."

But Boeing spokesman Gordon Johndroe said the company was restricted in how much it can divulge because of international protocol on crash investigations.

"As we've learned additional information, it's incumbent on us to be as transparent as possible," he said. "We know we have work to do to restore the trust of pilots and crews, international regulators and the traveling public."

- Shifting blame? -

A common link in both accidents was the Maneuvering Characteristics Augmentation System or MCAS, an automated flight handling program on the MAX that pointed the plane sharply downward based on a faulty sensor reading, hindering pilot control after takeoff, according to preliminary investigations.

Boeing has been working on what it calls a "software update" to the MCAS, which Muilenburg said will "break" a "common link" in both accidents.

Dennis Tajer, a pilot and spokesman for the Allied Pilots Association, said he has been encouraged by Boeing's drafts of the revamped system, which will ensure the MCAS is linked to two sensors instead of one and will no longer point full-nose down.

But he criticized Muilenburg's statement that the crashes resulted from a "chain of events."

"They were good when they said 'We own this,'" Tajer said. "When you say it's a chain of events, that's like a dog-whistle to us to blame the pilots."

Scott Hamilton, founder of Leeham Company, an aviation consultancy, also took issue with Boeing's characterizing of the MCAS problems.

"Using Boeing speak this is not a 'fix', this is an upgrade to make the system more robust," he said.

- Liability fears -

"They won't even acknowledge that this is a fix. And they certainly won't acknowledge this was a design flaw" due to worries about liability and criminal probes stemming from the accidents.

Hamilton said the company was further damaged by a "drip drip" of news stories that have painted a confusing picture about how the MCAS was supposed to work, why Boeing didn't respond earlier to signs of problems, and what it told customers and regulators, as well as concerns over a cozy relationship with aviation regulators.

But Scott Farrell, leader of the brand reputation group at Golin, a public relations firm, said Boeing was facing a "classic tug of war between managing a crisis with an eye on the court of law versus the court of public opinion," he said.

Boeing has "swung too far to the court of law approach."

US airlines have said they expect to return the 737 MAX to service over the summer. Yet carriers may face difficulties with public confidence even after regulators clear it to fly again.

Nearly half of 1,700 fliers questioned in a recent survey said they would wait a year after the 737 MAX's return to fly the plane, according to Barclays.

Barclays downgraded Boeing and conducted the survey because it suspected public apprehension about the planes "could be worse this time than following past incidents given social media and fliers' ability to know the aircraft type in advance of booking."

Related articles

Embattled Boeing to give $100 mn to 737 MAX crash victims' families

Pilots tell US Congress more training needed on 737 MAX

FAA chief says no 737 MAX fix yet ahead of fence-mending summit

Will FAA's plan for 737 MAX fly outside US?

20/08 Lufthansa boss sees only 'dozen' long-haul airlines in future
18/07 A look back at how the partnership between AFI KLM E&M and GMF AeroAsia was finalised
18/07 A bright future for AFI KLM E&M's activities
18/07 Jean Kayanakis (Dassault Aviation): "Customer service quality is now clearly a critical argument"
18/07 A very good Paris Air Show for Collins Aerospace's aftermarket activities
18/07 Air Support becomes a Meggitt approved repair station for high pressure engine valves
26 JUL 2019
ATR has created a new independent Operations Directorate within its Executive Committee, which was previously only a department integrated into the Programs and Customer Services Directorate. Reporting directly to the CEO Stefano Bortoli, it will be headed by RAPHAEL DUBUS, previously Accountable Manager of Production Organisation. He will take office on September 1 and join the Executive Committee.
18 JUL 2019
S7 TECHNICS has started to manufacture plastic products using vacuum thermoforming. The new method will allow the Russian MRO company to considerably expand the range of items it is able to produce for aircraft interiors. The first parts produced were plastic passenger seat backs that are being installed on S7 Airlines' Airbus A320 family of aircraft.
18 JUL 2019
AESL (Aircraft End-of-Life Solution) has acquired an Airbus A330-200 (MSN 195, PW4000, CS-TOI, ex-TAP) for dismantling. The aircraft will land at Twente airport in late July.
18 JUL 2019
AAR has won a four-year maintenance contract with the ROYAL NETHERLANDS AIR FORCE (RNLAF) to perform maintenance, repair and overhaul of the CH-47 Chinook APU for Logistics Centre Woensdrecht (LCW). The US MRO company has been present on the RNLAF F-16 fleet for more than 25 years. AAR will provide this new contract from its Component Repair facility in Amsterdam.
18 JUL 2019
SAFRAN HELICOPTER ENGINES and THAI AVIATION INDUSTRIES (TAI) have signed an agreement to extend their support to helicopter engines used by the Royal Thai Armed Forces and Thai parapublic operators. This agreement, which follows a previous partnership signed in 2017 for Makila turbines (H225), is based on a Global Support Package (GSP) and now covers around fifty engines.
ALERTAVIA, the News platform for Aerospace and Defense industry Professionals.

Featured Content
AFI KLM E&M steps up a gear on CFM's LEAP
Sabena technics finally gets back on-board C-130Hs
Airbus and Thai Airways to launch a new joint venture MRO facility at U-Tapao
How Thai Airways will Expand Rolls-Royce's Trent Engine Service Network
China embarks on board aircraft recycling
Follow us
© 2019 Le Journal de l'Aviation - All rights reserved

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. You can find out more by following this link.  OK  Find out more